Legal System of England and Wales
The Legal System paper tests how courts, precedent and legislation fit together: the civil and criminal court hierarchies, the doctrine of binding precedent, statutory interpretation, and the roles of the different legal professions.
It is foundational rather than glamorous, which is exactly why candidates underrate it. Questions are precise about which court binds which, and about the narrow exceptions to precedent.
- Civil and criminal court structure and appeal routes
- The doctrine of judicial precedent and its exceptions
- Statutory interpretation: literal, golden and mischief approaches
- Sources of law and the legal professions
See the format
Written for this page only, in the same single best answer format as the 160+ questions in the Legal System of England and Wales section of the course.
A County Court judge is deciding a claim on which a Court of Appeal decision is directly on point. The judge believes the reasoning is wrong, and notes that the decision conflicts with an earlier House of Lords authority the Court of Appeal did not consider. What should the judge do?
The exceptions that let a court depart from an otherwise binding Court of Appeal decision, including per incuriam, belong to the Court of Appeal when reviewing its own past decisions. They are not available to a court lower in the hierarchy, which stays bound regardless of an unconsidered conflicting authority or its own view of the reasoning. That conflict is a ground of appeal, not a basis for a lower court to depart on its own initiative.
Authority: Young v Bristol Aeroplane Co Ltd [1944] KB 718 (the Court of Appeal’s own exceptions to precedent).
Where Legal System of England and Wales connects
Unlock the full Legal System of England and Wales section
A free account unlocks the first section of Legal System of England and Wales, including its revision mind-map, immediately.